HSE web guidance, updated 17 March 2025
Over-protection
Current. Last checked with HSE on 11 November 2026.
Guidance on HSE's website.
- Kind
- HSE web guidance, updated 17 March 2025
- HSE's date
- 17 March 2025
- Last checked
- 11 November 2026
The passage you were sent
What it says, in HSE's own words
Protectors that reduce the level at the ear to below 70 dB should be avoided, since this over-protection may cause difficulties with communication and hearing warning signals. Users may become isolated from their environment, leading to safety risks, and generally may have a tendency to remove the hearing protection and therefore risk damage to their hearing. The table below gives an indication of the protector factor that is likely to be suitable for different levels of noise (the noise level during a particular work task, not the daily personal noise exposure).
It is based on the single number rating (SNR) value provided with a hearing protection device. The information is intended as a guide rather than a substitute for using one of the standardised methods for calculating hearing protection performance, and in particular will not be appropriate if there are significant low-frequency components to the noise in question.
Quoted from HSE. Open the original on hse.gov.uk
Key points
Hearing protectors that reduce the level at the ear to below 70 dB should be avoided, because over-protection may make communication and hearing warning signals difficult. Users may become isolated from their environment, creating safety risks, and may tend to remove the protection, risking hearing damage. The guidance gives an indication of a suitable protector factor for different noise levels during a particular work task, rather than daily personal noise exposure. It uses the single number rating (SNR) supplied with the device and is a guide, not a substitute for standardised methods of calculating performance. The table is not suitable where significant low-frequency noise is present, including press shops, generators, generator test bays, plant rooms, boiler houses, concrete shaker tables, moulding presses and punch presses. Select an SNR of 20 or less for 85-90 dB, 20-30 for 90-95 dB, 25-35 for 95-100 dB, and 30 or more for 100-105 dB.
Our summary of the document's own words. Check the original before you rely on it.
Machine-translated summary (Polish)
Należy unikać ochronników słuchu, które obniżają poziom przy uchu poniżej 70 dB, ponieważ nadmierna ochrona może utrudniać komunikację i słyszenie sygnałów ostrzegawczych. Użytkownicy mogą zostać odizolowani od otoczenia, co stwarza zagrożenia dla bezpieczeństwa, i mogą mieć skłonność do zdejmowania ochrony, narażając słuch na uszkodzenie. Wytyczne podają orientacyjny odpowiedni współczynnik ochronnika dla różnych poziomów hałasu podczas konkretnego zadania roboczego, a nie dla dziennego osobistego narażenia na hałas. Wykorzystują wartość jednoliczbowową (SNR) podaną dla urządzenia i stanowią wskazówkę, a nie zamiennik znormalizowanych metod obliczania skuteczności. Tabela nie jest odpowiednia, gdy występuje znaczny hałas o niskich częstotliwościach, w tym w tłoczniach, przy generatorach, w stanowiskach testowych generatorów, pomieszczeniach technicznych, kotłowniach, na stołach wibracyjnych do betonu, prasach do formowania i prasach wykrawających. Należy wybrać SNR 20 lub mniej dla 85-90 dB, 20-30 dla 90-95 dB, 25-35 dla 95-100 dB oraz 30 lub więcej dla 100-105 dB.
Machine-translated summary (Romanian)
Protectorii auditivi care reduc nivelul la ureche sub 70 dB trebuie evitați, deoarece protecția excesivă poate îngreuna comunicarea și auzirea semnalelor de avertizare. Utilizatorii se pot izola de mediul înconjurător, creând riscuri pentru siguranță, și pot avea tendința de a îndepărta protecția, riscând deteriorarea auzului. Îndrumările oferă un factor orientativ adecvat al protectorului pentru diferite niveluri de zgomot în timpul unei anumite sarcini de lucru, nu pentru expunerea personală zilnică la zgomot. Acestea folosesc valoarea numerică unică (SNR) furnizată împreună cu dispozitivul și reprezintă un ghid, nu un înlocuitor pentru metodele standardizate de calculare a performanței. Tabelul nu este potrivit atunci când există componente semnificative de joasă frecvență ale zgomotului, inclusiv în hale de presare, la generatoare, în standuri de testare a generatoarelor, în încăperi tehnice, centrale termice, mese vibratoare pentru beton, prese de turnare și prese de perforare. Selectați un SNR de 20 sau mai mic pentru 85-90 dB, 20-30 pentru 90-95 dB, 25-35 pentru 95-100 dB și 30 sau mai mult pentru 100-105 dB.
Check your RAMS against this document
Related guidance
- Advice on issuing hearing protection
- Wood working control risks
- Concrete and cement control risks
- Accounting for 'real world' factors
Tell me when HSE changes this
Tell me when HSE changes Over-protection. A line in the Monday email when HSE withdraws, replaces, moves or updates this document, and no email when it does not.
Contains public sector information published by the Health and Safety Executive and licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. KASQ is not affiliated with HSE.